Is Airline Elite Status Still Worth It? Analyzing the Shift
With United and Southwest changing their loyalty programs, the value of elite status is shifting. Here's what this means for points travelers and how to navigate the changes.
- Evaluate Spending Habits:
- Focus on Credit Card Partnerships:
- Maximize Point Redemptions:
- Domestic Flights:
As United Airlines and Southwest Airlines revamp their loyalty programs, the value of elite status is increasingly under scrutiny. This shift emphasizes spending over flying, prompting travelers to reassess their strategies.
What Does This Mean for Your Points?
The recent changes to United and Southwest's loyalty programs signal a significant shift in how airlines reward their most loyal customers. Traditionally, elite status was primarily achieved through the number of flights taken or miles flown. However, the new emphasis on spending means that travelers may need to adjust their approach to earning and utilizing points.
For points travelers, this change can have profound implications. With the focus on spending, those who fly less frequently but spend more on premium services may find themselves at an advantage. This could lead to a more exclusive club of elite members, potentially devaluing the status for those who previously relied on flight frequency alone.
How Can You Adapt to These Changes?
To navigate the evolving landscape of airline loyalty, travelers should consider a few strategies:
- Evaluate Spending Habits: Analyze your travel spending. If you typically purchase premium tickets or add extras like baggage or seat upgrades, you may already be in a favorable position under the new rules.
- Focus on Credit Card Partnerships: Many airlines have credit card partnerships that offer bonus points for spending. For example, United's co-branded credit cards often provide additional points for purchases, which can help you reach elite status faster.
- Maximize Point Redemptions: Understanding the best redemption sweet spots can help you make the most of your points, even if your elite status diminishes. For instance, United MileagePlus offers excellent value for international business class flights, often requiring fewer points than competitors.
What Are the Sweet Spots in United MileagePlus?
United MileagePlus has several redemption sweet spots that savvy travelers should keep in mind:
- Domestic Flights: Redeeming points for flights within the U.S. can often yield good value, especially during peak travel seasons when cash prices soar.
- International Business Class: United's MileagePlus program allows for some of the best business class redemptions to Europe and Asia, often requiring around 70,000 to 80,000 miles one-way, which can be a steal compared to cash prices that can exceed $5,000.
- Star Alliance Partners: Utilizing United's partnerships with other Star Alliance members can open up additional sweet spots, such as accessing premium cabins on airlines like Lufthansa or Singapore Airlines.
Is It Worth Transferring Points Now?
With the changes in elite status criteria, many travelers may wonder whether it's still worth transferring points from credit cards to airline programs. The answer largely depends on your travel goals:
Get points tips in your inbox
Fare alerts, points strategy guides, and exclusive sweet spots. No spam.
By subscribing you agree to receive emails from Pointify. Unsubscribe anytime.
- If you plan to fly frequently with United or Southwest and can meet the new spending thresholds, transferring points may still be beneficial.
- However, if you are a casual traveler or primarily fly on price rather than loyalty, it might be more advantageous to keep your points flexible in transferable programs like Chase Ultimate Rewards or American Express Membership Rewards.
What Are the Trade-Offs?
As with any loyalty program changes, there are trade-offs to consider:
- Increased Costs: The focus on spending may lead to higher overall costs for achieving elite status, particularly for those who previously relied on flying alone.
- Potential Devaluation: As airlines tighten the criteria for elite status, the perceived value of that status may decrease, making it less attractive for some travelers.
- More Competition: With spending becoming the primary metric, expect more competition for elite status among those who can afford to spend more on travel.
Frequently Asked Questions
How can I maintain my elite status with the new changes?
To maintain your elite status, focus on increasing your spending on flights and consider using airline co-branded credit cards to earn points faster.
Are there still benefits to having elite status?
Yes, elite status can still offer benefits such as priority boarding, free upgrades, and access to lounges, which can enhance your travel experience.
What should I do if I can't meet the new spending requirements?
If you can't meet the new requirements, consider shifting your focus to other airlines or loyalty programs that may offer better value based on your travel habits.
What are the best ways to redeem points now?
Look for sweet spots in the United MileagePlus program, particularly for international business class flights, and consider using points for high-value domestic flights during peak seasons.
About the author
Published
Zoheb Alvi covers points strategies, fare deals, and travel optimization for the Pointify blog.
Get points tips in your inbox
Fare alerts, points strategy guides, and exclusive sweet spots. No spam.
By subscribing you agree to receive emails from Pointify. Unsubscribe anytime.
Further Reading
Cash vs points: how to actually know which is cheaper
Points are not automatically a deal. Here is the simple cents-per-point math that tells you when to pay cash and when to burn miles — and a faster way to check both at once.
Transferable points 101: why flexible points beat a wall of one airline's miles
A huge balance in one airline program feels like wealth until that program devalues overnight. Flexible bank points transfer to many airlines and hotels — here is why that optionality is worth more than any single stash of miles.
Do Marriott Bonvoy Points Expire? 2026 Rules and How to Keep Them
Marriott Bonvoy points expire after 24 months of inactivity — but a single small transaction resets the clock. Here is exactly how the policy works, what counts as activity, and the cheapest way to keep your points forever.